Will US Attorneys Appeal after latest Ka Nefer Nefer setback?

A judge has dismissed the federal government’s request to reconsider an earlier ruling dismissing the government’s forfeiture request for the Ka Nefer Nefer mask currently on display at the St. Louis Art Museum. Rick St. Hilaire notes the U.S. Attorney must now make the decision whether to appeal the ruling on to the 8th Circuit. 


The problem with the government’s initial case—at least in the district court’s view—was the government failed to allege the particular circumstances under which a crime took place as the mask left Egypt. This problem can be examined by referencing recent case law broadening the principle that looted and smuggled objects are considered tainted when they leave their country of origin, even in the absence of direct evidence of wrongdoing. I’m thinking for example of the Barakat ruling in the English High Court which offered claimant nations a broader platform of potential laws with which a nation of origin can claim theft. 


But in this case the federal prosecutors had a difficult prospect as Egypt was unable to offer enough evidence establishing a crime had been committed. So despite the research the SLAM conducted when it acquired the mask in 1998, the government was unable to offer enough to convince a judge to forfeit the object and force SLAM to make its case. It is an open question whether the district court would have taken such rulings on board, likely not. But an appeals court is in a more favorable position to make broader inquiries in the law based on policy and foreign authority. 

Questions or Comments? Email me at derek.fincham@gmail.com

3 thoughts on “Will US Attorneys Appeal after latest Ka Nefer Nefer setback?”

  1. The attorney can also find out about the plea bargain and sentence bargain.
    Some of the facts that the best representation available will be looking for,
    is whether the police stopped you without having just cause,
    they did not inform you of your rights that you have to gain the assistance of an attorney, the breathalyzer test was
    undependable, or the officer took blood from you on site.
    When courts are responsible for a large number of cases, these public defenders might have a large number of cases
    to go through at the same time.

    Visit my blog: DUI Lawyer In Fort Myers

  2. Now that laser hair removal and other semi-permanent methods of
    hair reduction are on the market, becoming hair free is easier and less
    expensive. While the plugins in this group don’t offer the customization options found in many other selections, they do provide some very interesting effects by modifying color hues or brightness and
    by applying special warp settings. 2) It is not beneficial for red,
    blonde and gray hair. The Photo – Wiz Photo – Freebies collection
    contains 11 different plugins that are quite useful
    when making color adjustments to a digital photograph.
    Not all products give only its benefit, but always expect that the disadvantage and the negative result is also a part of it.

    Also visit my site :: DUI Lawyer In Tampa

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *